Anne L. Gunther
It would
sound cruel if I began a tribute to my mother who passed away one week ago
today with a sense that I’m glad she’s gone. No, phrasing is everything. Instead, my feelings that I am grateful her suffering is over is closer
to the truth. And it sounds more civilized.
Watching
arthritis slowly overcome her body during the last few years was heart
breaking. I have realized that perhaps
there is a definite place in our lives for end of life suffering. The memories of those last months are
definitely making it easier to let her go.
And the
other memories leading up to these last years have crept up to the front of my
mind in recent weeks when my brother and I and our families knew that the end
was near. Memories such as…
The time when
we were still living in the Frankford section of Philadelphia, and Mom would sometimes
meet us at our school, H.R. Edmunds (now a charter school specializing in music
education). We had an hour for
lunch, which allowed us time to walk the
five blocks home, eat, and walk back for the afternoon classes. One time, she made tuna salad sandwiches and
in those days Mom would take the extra step by cutting the crusts off. This made the meal seem more like a high tea
rather than an elementary school lunch.
So this one
day she left the sandwiches resting on paper towels on our kitchen table and
left the house to meet us. We returned
home, Mom announced that lunch was on the table and we went to the kitchen,
finding not sandwiches, but vacant paper towels. It seems that Mom had not counted on Champ,
our Belgium Shepherd, detecting that something delectable was on
the kitchen
table and helping himself. I’m sure she had
some choice words for dad that night when she told him what “his” dog had done.
Another
elementary school story, hitherto unknown to everyone beyond my Mom and me,
since I have never discussed it since the day it happened. My friend Teddy Wolf and I were walking
through the schoolyard at lunchtime (Mom didn’t meet us this day) when we saw a
group of kids bent over in what appeared to be a football huddle. I said, “Hey, let’s see what they’re
doing.” Teddy had some premonition and
said something that we probably shouldn’t bother them, but I proceeded
undeterred.
I said,
“Whatcha doing?” One kid grabbed me,
pulled me inside the huddle and said, “This is what we’re doing.” The problem was that the kid grabbed me by
the neck and tightened his grip around my throat until I started screaming and
crying. He let me go and I cried the
rest of the way home. (BTW, the kids were
lighting matches using a magnifying glass. Big whoop!)
I told Mom
what happened and, after lunch and calming me down, we walked together back to
school and the principal’s office. She
told him what had happened and all three of us went to one of the classrooms on
the third floor where the upperclassmen (sixth graders) were learning or otherwise
being indoctrinated into the post nuclear age way of American life. The principal told the teacher what had
happened and I was given the chance to see if I could identify who had grabbed
me. There was one problem: I hadn’t seen the faces of any of the kids in
the huddle. Also given my height at that
time I could not see any faces because I could, at best, see only the bottoms of
the polished wood desk tops.
Every once
in awhile, the memory of that day comes back to me and I have since concluded
that the kid didn’t mean to harm me, but perhaps didn’t know the strength of
his grip. Whatever, I’ve made it a point
to avoid crowds (from more than three people to 100 people) ever since.
Mom was one
of five daughters born to Jack and Bonnie Cathers (there were also two boys)
and she was the last of the daughters to get married. Unfortunately, I’ve never seen any photographs
of my parent’s nuptials, probably because none exist. Just as well, as it is may have been the
happiest day of her life, but a few incidents that day probably dampened her
enthusiasm.
For one
thing, there were religious differences: Dad was Catholic and Mom was
Protestant. Grandmom, thinking that
there must be a good reason why her only son was marrying a Protestant girl,
assumed that they had to get married. She asked Mom bluntly if she was pregnant. Mom was not expecting, and the incident set
the tone of their strained relationship forever after.
Then there
was the more dramatic reaction from Dad’s sisters. They cried,
not for the usual reason that weddings are a happy event that evokes
tears, but they were convinced that their baby brother
was going to burn in Hell because he was a marrying a Protestant. This reaction has baffled every Catholic
person I told this story to, but all I can figure out is this is how people
believed in 1957.
My parents
got married for reasons that were more economic than starting a family. Dad reported for active duty in the Navy two
days after the ceremony, and the marriage allowed Mom to receive whatever
benefits would be available to anyone married to a person serving in the armed
forces. Mom and Dad
remained married, happily as far as I know, despite their different religious
upbringings. There were also political
differences: Dad was conservative, while
Mom was more progressive thinking, being a supporter of the Equal Rights
Amendment. I’ll never forget my
discomfort the day after the ERA ratification deadline had expired and Mom
yelled at me, “I’m still a second class citizen.”
Okay, Mom,
gee, sorry about that.
Both of my
parents served on the Catawissa town council, at different times and from different
political parties. Mom felt comfortable
being a Democrat because she believed they looked out for the little guy. Due to their political allegiances, they were
known as the Odd Couple of Catawissa Politics. So naturally everyone probably believes that over the years my brother
and I witnessed many spirited discussions at the dinner table. The truth is disappointing: politics was never discussed at dinner time,
save for the activities of the other people on the council.
As far as I know, Mom was a lifelong Christian Scientist. My brother and I were both raised in this religion, but, despite my Mom’s best efforts, we have both drifted away from it. Of the two of us, she realized that I had a better understanding of it, which is probably why she confided to me in one of our final phone conversations that she wanted to use prayer to work through her situation. We talked the day before she was admitted to the hospital with pneumonia. No doubt she probably found all this medical attention with feeding tubes, IV tubes, and talk of intubating her to facilitate clearing her lungs annoying.
The last few
weeks I have found myself thinking about Mom’s religious beliefs and – apologies
for this left turn in my narrative — something Michael Nesmith said when his
fellow Monkee Davey Jones passed away a few years ago. Nesmith is also the offspring of a Christian
Scientist, and he reacted to Jones’ death with a description of death as
transition. He alluded to it as part of
a journey in our existences. So when
we, family and friends of Anne Gunther, gather this weekend for her service, I
don’t believe we are saying goodbye. Rather
we are seeing her off on the next stage of her existence.
I did not say goodbye to Mom when I saw her for the last time at the hospital. I just said, “I’ll talk to you later.”
And that’s how this will end: Mom, I’ll talk to you later.
(Thank you for reading.)